Documents · 13 May 2000
Declaration on the Founding
of the Apostolic Orthodox Church.
The Declaration by which bishops and priests of the True Orthodox (Catacomb) Church announced the formation of the Apostolic Orthodox Church and named its reforms.
We, the bishops and priests of the True Orthodox (Catacomb) Church, by this Declaration announce the formation of the Apostolic Orthodox Church.
We seek to carry out comprehensive and consistent reforms for the good of the Church of Christ, the preaching of the Gospel and Russian Orthodoxy.
Among these reforms are the following.
1. Decentralisation of church authority and a return to the apostolic tradition of church governance
The need for such a reform was described in 1932 by S. Troitsky, professor of canon law: “The era of union with the state divided the Orthodox Church into large organisations analogous to the state and sharing its territorial borders, and created the urge to preserve at all costs the unbroken unity of church administration. This kind of ecclesiastical imperialism is the main cause of present-day church disorders… We must drive out of the Church, in the words of the Council of Carthage, ‘the smoky arrogance of the world’, and give up the urge to turn the Orthodox Church into several weak copies of the Roman Catholic Church... It is fitting to recall that at the time of the first Ecumenical Council there were about a hundred autocephalous Churches.”
And here is the opinion of I. S. Aksakov: “The invention of the Emperor Justinian and his officials, as a parallel to the civil prefects. The ‘poly-papism’ of the patriarchal system is worse than Roman ‘mono-papism’. In true Orthodoxy, authority over bishops and local Churches belongs only to Councils, not to patriarchs and metropolitans.”
From absolute monarchy, which at times degenerates into an Eastern despotism with the harshest vertical of power, the Orthodox Church must return to a conciliar order. The supreme executive authority in the Church (the Synod) must not appoint or dismiss bishops or transfer them from one diocese to another (without their consent and that of the Church). That right belongs only to diocesan assemblies (once the appropriate procedures are worked out). Both the episcopate and the clergy are elected and dismissed only by the parish assembly on the proposal of the bishop and the diocesan council. Church authority must have three branches: legislative, executive and judicial. We particularly stress the indelibility of holy orders and the undesirability of disciplinary penalties.
To restore the “Holy of Holies” of the life of the Church, conciliarity. Local Councils, the supreme authority in the Church, must be convened strictly regularly, at least once every three years.
We reject the geographical, national-territorial principle of “canonical territory”, which is in essence a medieval relic of serfdom in the organisation of the state carried over into church life. This principle, widely applied in Orthodoxy, ultimately leads the Church to spiritual stagnation and, moreover, to its inevitable dependence on the state. This is what Vladimir Solovyov wrote: “Spiritual authority cannot be independent of secular authority if the Church exists within the limits of a single state. A national Church is always part of the state and will always depend on worldly power.”
The true unity of the Church lies not in organisational structures but in the spirit of brotherly love, in unity of faith, in the confession of the truths of doctrine and the principles of spiritual life. Although the Orthodox Church is universal in character, Orthodox Churches in fact exist as independent Local Churches, and this in no way diminishes the unity of the Church of Christ.
2. Liturgical and disciplinary reforms
We consider it possible for Russia to adopt the Gregorian calendar style, following most Orthodox Churches, according to the wish of the faithful.
The system of church awards, which breeds careerism and corruption, must be abolished.
It is permissible to relax the rigid practice of fasting, without laying on the faithful burdens hard to bear and leaving ascetic effort to the conscience of each.
Services may be celebrated in any language the faithful wish, including Russian.
Every service must without fail be accompanied by a sermon.
We consider it necessary:
- To remove from church practice compulsory charges for services and rites (fees for rites).
- To simplify Orthodox worship, freeing it from Byzantine pomp. Where necessary, to permit the shortening of services, while leaving those who wish free to celebrate them according to the monastic order.
- To open the sanctuary to a greater participation of the faithful in worship. To move the altar table to the middle of the church (at the wish of the faithful).
- To establish strict control and transparency over all the financial flows of church organisations at every level.
Trusting in the mercy of God, in the prayers of the host of the New Martyrs and Confessors of Russia and of the enlightener and hieromartyr Alexander Men, whom we venerate, we believe that our Church, entering the third millennium, will serve the cause of preaching the Resurrection of Christ.
Moscow, 13 May 2000