Documents · 17 March 2013
Clarification of the Synod
on the order of the Church.
Clarification of the Holy Synod of the Apostolic Orthodox Church on the order and structure of the Church and on the procedure for receiving clergy and communities of other Churches under its omophorion.
The Holy Synod of the Apostolic Orthodox Church (AOC) often receives both questions about the order of our Church and petitions from individual clergy and communities of other Churches to be received under the omophorion of the Church.
In this connection the Holy Synod gives the following clarifications.
Spiritual roots
The spiritual roots of the Apostolic Orthodox Church go back to the Russian True Orthodox (Catacomb) Church, in which Archpriest Alexander Men was baptised. The Church is open to all Orthodox Christians, liberals and conservatives alike, since the spiritual revival of Orthodoxy rests at once on the constant renewal of the Church by the Holy Spirit and on the careful preservation of Holy Tradition.
Not a Local Church
The Apostolic Orthodox Church is not a Local Church, neither Russian nor Ukrainian, nor subject to any other state or territory. Its very name bears witness to this, the Apostolic Orthodox Church, as distinct from, say, the Russian Orthodox Church (ROC), the Ukrainian Orthodox Church of the Moscow Patriarchate (UOC MP), the Ukrainian Autocephalous Orthodox Church (UAOC) and so on. The Declaration on the Founding of the Church states, in particular (point 3): “We reject the geographical, national-territorial principle of ‘canonical territory’, which is in essence a medieval relic of serfdom in the organisation of the state carried over into church life...” The Apostolic Orthodox Church is also registered as a centralised religious organisation under the name “Association of Orthodox Communities of the Apostolic Tradition”. Our canonical territory is wherever we are needed and wherever we are received.
The Primate
According to the Collection of Canons of the Church (adopted at the Council of 2008), the office of Primate of the Church is elective. The Primate is elected from among the bishops by the Council of the Church and performs the organising, coordinating, supervisory and representative functions of church governance delegated to him. The Primate of the Church is first among equals among the bishops of the Church. At present Metropolitan Vitaly (Kuzhevatov) has been elected to this office.
Where the bishop is, there is the Church
The Apostolic Orthodox Church professes the principle set out long ago by Saint Ignatius the God-bearer: “Without the bishop there is no Church: wherever the bishop appears, there let the people be, just as wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the Catholic (Universal) Church...” (Letter to the Smyrnaeans, chapter VIII). Where the bishop is, there is the Church. The Apostolic Orthodox Church is in fact a confederation of independent local Churches united by the holy principle of conciliarity: “In essentials unity, in doubtful matters liberty, in all things charity...” (Blessed Augustine). On this basis every bishop of the Church is entitled to receive under his omophorion (direct jurisdiction) any community, cleric or lay person at their request.
Conditions of reception under the omophorion
The principle of reception under the omophorion of the Apostolic Orthodox Church is simple and fully accords with the teaching of the Church of Christ: “God opposes the proud, but gives grace to the humble...” (James 4:6). The ministry of the bishop consists chiefly in guarding the Church from “what has been sacrificed to idols” (ritualism) and from “blood” (aggression and intolerance, the spirit of violence and covetousness), from “what is strangled” (dogmatism) and from “fornication” (with the world): see Acts 15:29. As the Apostle also instructs: “Not to associate with anyone who bears the name of brother or sister who is sexually immoral or greedy, or is an idolater, reviler, drunkard, or robber. Do not even eat with such a one...” (1 Corinthians 5:11). The most important criterion is humility, since Orthodoxy is above all a spirit of humble wisdom, expressed in the mystical experience of the Church of Christ.
Three means, three levers the Lord has given to the pastors of the Church so that they may successfully fulfil the ministry entrusted to them: the word (spiritual understanding of Scripture, preaching, a clear understanding of the way), the sacraments (spiritual sense, the practice of faith) and church discipline. “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations (the word), baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit (the sacraments), and teaching them to obey everything that I have commanded you (church discipline)…” (Matthew 28:19–20). Teach, baptise, and go on teaching in the church community. Today nominal Orthodoxy has in effect cast aside two of these, the word and church discipline, as unnecessary or of little use, and tries to lead its flock into the Kingdom of God by sacraments and rites alone. “Accursed is the one who is slack in doing the work of the Lord” (Jeremiah 48:10). Church ministry must be taken seriously. Spiritual understanding, a humble faith working through love, and church discipline: these are the three conditions for reception under our omophorion (the last being expressed, among other things, in a voluntary tithe for the needs of the whole Church).
Clergy under penalty
The Holy Synod of the Church recommends the following to all the bishops of our Church. If a cleric or lay person who wishes to come under the omophorion of the Apostolic Orthodox Church is under a penalty (suspension from ministry, or from eucharistic or church communion), let him have the ban lifted through repentance and then retire from the clergy staff. An exception may be a case where the ban was imposed not for specific sins or offences but for inner convictions. If the former ruling bishop does not accept the repentance, there is no sin that can overcome the mercy of God. Such cases must be examined by our bishops with particular care, and only after this should the question of reception under the omophorion of the Church be decided.
Community statutes
There is no need whatever to re-register the statutes of independent Orthodox communities that come under the omophorion of the Apostolic Orthodox Church. For example, the community of the Resurrection of Christ in Lutsk (Ukraine), in accordance with its own Statute, retains its status and name, “Independent Orthodox Religious Community of the Resurrection of Christ, Lutsk”, and is hierarchically subordinate to the rector of the community and the ruling bishop.
The Holy Synod greets all the clergy and laity of the Apostolic Orthodox Church at the beginning of Great Lent and calls on them to prepare worthily for the radiant feast of the Resurrection of Christ.
Signatures
Primate of the Apostolic Orthodox Church + Metropolitan Vitaly
Secretary of the Synod of the Apostolic Orthodox Church Protopresbyter Gleb Yakunin
Forgiveness Sunday, Moscow, 17 March 2013