Apostolic Orthodox ChurchCommunities of the apostolic tradition
EN

Documents · 31 January 2000

Declaration of the Movement
“For the Revival of Orthodoxy”.

The Declaration of the Public Movement “For the Revival of Orthodoxy” on the spiritual crisis of Orthodoxy in Russia and on fifteen points of church reform.

Moscow, 31 January 2000

Orthodoxy in Russia today is in a state of deepening spiritual crisis, whose roots go deep into our centuries-long history.

The unhealthy spiritual state of the Church was noted, almost before anyone else, by the great Russian writers. We need only recall the words of F. M. Dostoevsky: “The Russian Church has been paralysed since Peter the Great.” Or those of I. S. Aksakov: “Neither the Russian nor the Slavic world will rise again, nor find wholeness and freedom, so long as the Church remains in such deadness.” Or the bitter conclusion reached by that most attentive and conscientious student of our country’s church life, N. S. Leskov: “Russia has been baptised, but not enlightened.”

The ways out of this crisis and the possibilities of renewing the Church were the subject of intense reflection by outstanding Russian thinkers: V. S. Solovyov, Archpriest S. Bulgakov, S. L. Frank, G. P. Fedotov. Unfortunately, all this rich heritage of Christian thought, which could have become the foundation of a true revival of Orthodoxy in Russia, lies essentially unused. The present leadership of the Moscow Patriarchate treats it either with icy indifference or with undisguised hostility; matters have gone as far as public autos-da-fé, in whose flames perish the books of Russian Orthodox theologians and philosophers recognised by the whole world.

At the beginning of the twentieth century the Orthodox clergy began actively to discuss the problems of the revival of the Church. The highest hierarchs of the Church called for the speedy convening of a Local Council, which was to begin the long-awaited church reforms.

In 1905 the “Union for Church Renewal” was formed in Petersburg, uniting priests and laity sincerely concerned for the destiny of Orthodoxy in Russia.

It is time at last to tell the truth about those who for many decades have been called “Renovationists”, giving a disparaging sense to the New Testament notion of “renewal”. It is time to acknowledge that many of their ideas were theologically justified and urgently needed.

At the heart of this spiritual movement lay the conviction that there must be a genuine separation of Church and state, the liberation of the Church from state tutelage, the decentralisation of church governance, the introduction of Conciliar governance through democratically elected Church Councils, Diocesan Congresses and Parish Assemblies of clergy and laity, the mandatory election of bishops and priests, the financial openness of Church organisations at every level, and the active participation of the Church in the life of society, in social service, and in the education and moral formation of the people.

In the field of liturgical reform it was proposed to introduce living Russian in place of the barely comprehensible Slavonic, and to celebrate with the Royal Doors open and with the “secret” prayers read aloud.

In accordance with the 4th canon of the 4th Ecumenical Council, which states: “Let monastics not meddle in either ecclesiastical or worldly affairs, nor take part in them, leaving their monasteries”, the first generation of the renewal movement proposed giving up the monastic monopoly on authority in the Church. “The monasticism of bishops,” wrote A. D. Aksakov, “is a phenomenon in the Church that is... anti-canonical.” Monastic service requires silence, contemplation and withdrawal from worldly bustle. The early Church placed the monastic struggle above the priestly and episcopal ministry, and therefore did not allow monastic vows to be broken for the sake of the episcopate.

After the February Revolution of 1917 the Local Council of the All-Russian Orthodox Church was at last convened and began its work. But in the course of its three sessions it managed to carry out only some of the urgent reforms. In September 1918, under pressure from the Bolsheviks, the Council ceased its work.

Even so, the Council managed to take several decisions of the greatest importance that carried out the programme of church reform, in particular: new statutes and new conciliar structures for the whole Church, from the Patriarch (who was recognised only as first among equal bishops) down to self-governing parishes, granting broad initiative at every level of the Church to the ordinary clergy and laity, and the elective principle for the episcopate and clergy.

The regular holding of Local Councils at least once every three years was established, and of diocesan and parish assemblies still more often, and the sovereign right of ownership of all movable and immovable property was secured to the parishes (the church building and all church property).

At the same time the renewal movement began to gather strength. Its subsequent fate, however, was tragic. On the one hand, it began to put into practice the necessary church reforms, of which one of the leaders of Renovationism, Alexander Vvedensky, said: “What is needed is liturgical creativity, bringing the liturgical language closer to life, the liberation of the human in communion with the Divine... the sweeping away of what is superficial and formal, the deepening of the inner understanding of religion. The priesthood must come out of the archaeological museum onto the path of free and religious life and understand the true essence of religion. The salvation of the Church lies in its going out into the world, not in standing still in religious slumber. Life will compel us to believe this!”.

On the other hand, the leadership of the Renovationists could not avoid extreme servility and was skilfully used by the Communist Party and the GPU to undermine the Church from within, to split it and to fight against the patriarchal Church and personally against Patriarch Tikhon. As a result the renewal movement was discredited in the eyes of the faithful, and the church reforms were doomed to failure.

Alongside deeply principled and zealous supporters of reform, such as Bishop Antonin (Granovsky) and the priest Alexander Boyarsky, the Movement included outright agents of the GPU, such as the priest Vladimir Krasnitsky. By their vicious attacks on Patriarch Tikhon, on Metropolitan Veniamin of Petersburg and his companions, who were tried and shot in the case of the seizure of church valuables, and by their collaboration with the God-fighting authorities, persons such as Krasnitsky destroyed every aspiration to the renewal and spiritual revival of Orthodoxy in Russia.

After crushing Tikhon’s patriarchal Church in the 1930s, the Bolsheviks turned on their former wards, the Renovationists. Their fate was finally sealed after 1946, when some 500 remaining Renovationist parishes were deregistered by the state authorities and forcibly handed over to the Moscow Patriarchate.

The attempt at Orthodox renewal and revival at the beginning of the twentieth century was thwarted by the Bolsheviks, who for a time staked on supporting the renewal movement in the struggle against Tikhon’s Church. They succeeded in achieving a threefold effect: 1) splitting the Church, 2) weakening its spiritual and political influence on the people, and 3) discrediting in the eyes of the believing people everything connected with the renewal of the Church.

Having sharply changed his policy towards religion in 1943, Stalin staked on the most archaic, ossified, pro-imperial synodal model of the Church (one that suited his political line). It was soon headed by Alexy I (Simansky), an opponent of church reform.