Declaration of the Public Movement “For the Revival of Orthodoxy”
Witness and appeal
In the present critical situation, which brings an entire Local Church to the brink of spiritual ruin, we consider it our duty to bear witness before God and before all the believing people to the following:
- The Moscow Patriarchate is rapidly losing its spiritual authority. To survive it needs the props of the state. In honest spiritual contest it cannot withstand competition even from so-called “religious sects” of little influence. Yet society needs a real spiritual revival. The root of the crisis that has struck our country lies not only in political or economic instability but in the state of our society, which is to a considerable extent shaped by the Moscow Patriarchate, which with the help of the civil authorities has seized the “canonical spiritual space” of Russia.
- The Orthodox Church must move away from an order modelled on totalitarian dictatorship and acquire a confederal canonical order. The highest hierarchical authority in the Church is the bishop, the head of a diocese, as it was in apostolic times. The bishops who head dioceses are entitled to unite in a single church structure, but only with consultative and coordinating rights. Such a structure must have no administrative functions and no right to appoint or dismiss bishops. That right must belong only to diocesan assemblies (once the appropriate procedures have been worked out).
- Bishops and priests must be elected (and retired) only by the people themselves, by diocesan (parish) assemblies on the proposal of the diocesan council.
- The ordination to the episcopate of an unmarried or married priest without the requirement of taking monastic vows must be permitted.
- The Church must have three branches of authority: legislative, executive and judicial.
- By now most Orthodox Churches have already moved to the new Gregorian style (the only exceptions being the most conservative Churches: the Russian, Serbian and Jerusalem Churches). One direction of the necessary reform is the move of the Orthodox Church in Russia to the new style. Such a move must not be compulsory: parishes that do not wish to support calendar reform must have the right to use the Julian calendar.
- The harsh discipline of the severe fasts that now exist in Orthodoxy must be revised within reasonable limits.
- With the consent of the faithful, Orthodox worship should be simplified and shortened, freeing it from excessive Byzantine pomp.
- The complex multi-level system of church awards and pompous titles, which breeds vanity, careerism and corruption, must be abolished.
- Services must be celebrated in any language the faithful wish, and first of all in Russian.
- Every service must without fail be accompanied by a sermon.
- Any charges for services and rites must be removed from church practice.
- The sanctuary must be opened to a greater participation of the faithful in worship and, at the wish of the faithful, the altar table moved to the middle of the church.
- Openness of the financial reports of church organisations at every level must be revived.
- The regular convening of diocesan and local councils must be restored.
We hope for the revival of the Church despite its present calamitous state. We believe that the time is not far off when it will be transformed from a bureaucratic department into a truly free Church of Christ, devoted to God and serving the people.
But such a revival cannot come about without the active participation of the episcopate, the clergy and all the believing people.
We call on all Orthodox Christians to take part in the movement for the revival of Orthodoxy.
If church reforms do not take place today, then tomorrow Orthodoxy will be finally doomed to self-isolation, doomed to end up in a relic religious zone.
Moscow, 31 January 2000